On torspec!40, Mike says:
I don't think there is a practical difference here. As per
Section 2.4.5, if 60 seconds is not enough and causes the
liveness test to fail due to too many timeouts, we will double
the initial timeout.
This makes our behavior the same as C tor.
The C Tor implementation doesn't do this, and Mike says:
I think it is a reasonable enough assumption that if Tor has
restarted, this kind data is no longer fresh enough to be
accurate for this purpose. This is also only 20 circuits here,
and typical timeouts are now around 1-2 seconds or less.. So a
restarted client with a timeout that is too low for a new
internet connection will figure this out pretty quickly. I think
that is OK.
(from torspec!40)
Jani Monoses
Daniel Eades
Nick Mathewson